Damascus is a unique wavy pattern that you’ll find in steel with a certain aesthetic appeal. One of the most pressing concerns that modern times knife-lovers face is whether Damascus steel is real or fake.
To simplify, there are two methods that you can ensure whether Damascus steel is real or not: by checking whether they are Wootz steel and pattern-welded steel. In order to find whether the Damascus blade is real or counterfeit, let’s move on and delve deeper into the article.
What is Damascus Steel?
Before we go over the main part of the article, it is imperative to understand what Damascus steel is and how it originated. This will help you better understand the history of steel and why it is so special.
Damascus steel was originally founded in India and was later passed on to the East by the blacksmiths in India. Eventually, the steel was introduced in Damascus, Syria. Many people have different theories about why steel is called Damascus, but that is a different story.
The first account of original Damascus steel was recorded in the third century, and it was called Wootz back then. The steel was formed by melting chunks of iron and steel in pots of clay.
The mystery that unfolds is that blacksmiths today do not really know how the so called Damascus steel is made, as the true way of creating it was lost somewhere in the 17th century when the people who knew the right way of making it passed away. To date, no one really knows what kind of alloy was used in the making of Damascus. However, people have tried to mimic the process of creating the same Damascus steel and have come fairly close.
How is It Made Today?
Let’s take a look at the process of how Damascus steel is made. According to the Association for Renaissance Martial Arts, the following is the way of producing Damascus steel, which is the closest to the original.
The first step involves melting chunks of charcoal, iron and steel, and in an oxygen-reduced atmosphere. In this process, the two metals absorb the carbon from the charcoal, and the alloy that is created is cooled at a slow rate. This process results in a material with a clear crystalline structure containing various carbide contents.
By forging the alloy into a shape that you like will alter the crystalline structure into the familiar wavy Damascus pattern, which is what Damascus is popular for. This technique takes a lot of time and is highly labor-intensive. It also requires a high level of skill in order to keep the temperatures steady throughout the process.
Pattern-Welded Damascus Steel
This type of steel is what people call Damascus today. It refers to about 99.9% of the Damascus steel that you see in the markets today. In order to produce this kind of steel, the process is similar to the one mentioned above.
The two different types of steel (or more) are forged and folded together so that they complement each other. Acid etching is then done to reveal the differences in the steel forms. Acid etching is a process that involves a sheet metalworking technology that utilizes acid etchants to create highly accurate and complex metal components. This process helps in creating the wavy pattern that Damascus steel is famous for. Typical pattern-welded steel blades have about 40 layers of sheet metal. The Damascus blades are then polished to make the folds more visible. With this, the twisty patterns are also more prominent.
Pattern-welded steel actually got lost and was out of fashion for a considerable amount of time before it was brought back by Bill Moran in 1970. Sometimes, you will also find knives with VG-10 Damascus written on top of them. This process involves a VG-10 core with Damascus steel on both sides of the knife/blade. The steel is then laminated in San Mai’s mold, and the three layers of steel are squashed in together.
Real or Fake Damascus Steel: How to Know the Difference?
Now we move on to the most important part of the article. Here we will discuss how you can actually know whether the knife is a real Damascus or not. There are certain methods that manufacturers employ in order to imitate the real Damascus pattern, and some knife enthusiasts can tell from a single glance whether it is fake Damascus or not. In case you cannot, here are some of the ways that you can:
Both the Wootz and the pattern-welded steel techniques have acid etching as a crucial step on the steel blades, as that is what brings out the wavy and twisty design. However, some producers can fake the Damascus pattern welding by utilizing acid or laser etching techniques only to the stainless steel or carbon steel blades. These knives or blades are fake Damascus, as they are only made for the intention of aesthetics and are naturally cheap blades. They do not contain the innate qualities of a original Damascus steel blade, which is what you are looking for.
It can be difficult to spot whether a knife is a real Damascus with the naked eye, so you need to run it through some tests to determine whether the steel blade is real Damascus. One way you can check is to polish a portion of the blade until the pattern welding is no longer visible. Then stick the blade into an acid solution. If the Damascus is manufactured using the wootz or the pattern-welded method, the original design will reveal itself even after being submerged in the acid solution. In the fake Damascus steel blades, the edge of the knife will be uniform, leaving a randomly marked surface.
According to authentic historical methods, creating Damascus using Wootz steel is a lost art, which is why pattern welding is the most common and original method of creating Damascus. So, if you have a pattern-welded Damascus steel that has been acid-etched, it is a legitimate Damascus blade and a real Damascus knife.
How to Determine if the Damascus I have is Real?
There are a couple of signs that you can use to determine whether the Damascus knife is real or not. Firstly, if the blade has highly detailed and unnatural designs on it that are twisty, or wavy, then it is most likely a counterfeit.
Additionally, you can examine the consistency of the patterns on the Damascus knife to determine whether it is real or not. A real Damascus knife will have uniform folds and patterns all across the blade, the blade’s spine, cutting edge bolster, and the knife’s tang. If the folds are also visible on the knife’s butt, then that is another sign of original Damascus steel.
Misconceptions Regarding Damascus
One of the misconceptions that people harbor when purchasing Damascus knives is that if the knives don’t have pattern folds in the spine, they are not real. However, this statement is purely circumstantial, as Damascus steel can be polished, and this process is done to make the blade look more aesthetically pleasing.
In some cases, the knife’s butt and bolster are polished using brass, while the spine is polished and goes under treatment to include decorative work. This is why it is important to look for other signs when buying a Damascus steel, such as the consistency of the folds on the blade.
Another misconception that is common is that knives that don’t undergo acid etching aren’t Damascus knives. This is highly untrue, as both real pattern-welded and wootz steel knives undergo acid retching after the polishing process to make the patterns on the blade more visible. However, if the acid or laser etching is done on cheaper blades such as carbon steel or stainless steel without any layering, that’s when you know the Damascus steel is a fake.
Frequently Asked Questions
If you still have any questions related to Damascus steel and its types of steel, you can go over the following frequently asked questions to clear out some of your doubts. These will help you get a clearer idea or insight about the different types of Damascus steel in the market and guide you in choosing the right one:
Is Kershaw Damascus Blade Real?
The Kershaw Damascus Skyline LinerLock Knife with G-10 Handles is a true Damascus, as according to many customers, it passed the test of being polished and having the patterns and folds still intact. It is a lightweight and unique steel that has good ergonomics and is truly original.
The Kershaw Damascus Steel Leek knife, however, is not an original as the steel knife failed to pass the portion-polish test. It is also a cheap knife that is made of stainless steel and is not very durable or long-wearing. It is, however, a good steel knife that does the job well.
What is Alabama Damascus Steel?
Alabama Damascus Steel is a company that was founded by Brad Vice, who started off by producing steel billets as well as readymade blades to fulfill the needs of survivalists and adventurers. It is located in the mountain hills of Jacksonville in Alabama, and the company molds steel billets, which are used with large air hammers and are available in the market in unique patterns.
All of the blades in the brand are laser cut, hollow ground heat-treated, etched and precision-grounded. The brand is known to offer a wide range of Damascus billets, Damascus knife blade blanks, and guards, which are loved by knife enthusiasts and professionals.
Most of the users of Alabama Damascus knives are impressed with their purchase. The steel is of high quality, and the process used to make these knives is exactly how Damascus knives are made. They live up to the hype, which is why they are worth the price.
Is it Worth the Money?
Blades that are commercially sold as “Damascus” usually have different origins:
- They are either antique blades which are made using Wootz steel or using pattern-welded steel, which is the historical way of making them.
- The blades are forged and then sandwiched into layers of different or same metals to design the wavy pattern, or stainless steel knives are acid-etched to give the aesthetic appeal only.
Most of the forged Damascus knives are cheaply designed with the stainless steel blades acid or laser etched. This gives it the aesthetic appeal that most people look for, but it doesn’t prove that it’s of high quality. They are not worth the extra money that is put into the design, as their practical performance falls short of regular kitchen knives, which are cheaper and cut better.
In fact, according to material science, opting for a blade that is made with a single metal alloy with sturdiness is far better than laminating the knife with different molds and polishes to make it look aesthetically pleasing. Since these fake Damascus blades are only designed from ordinary steel, they tend to rust faster, and the knife itself is quite high maintenance if you want the design to stay intact.
The modern-day Damascus is made up of multiple layers of stainless steel, which may have a less prominent pattern but is definitely sturdier due to its high carbon concentration. This blade is more expensive than counterfeit ones, but it is also super sharp and high in terms of quality. This blade will hold its cutting edge much longer and be more durable because of all its metallic layers, making it more versatile and worthy of investment.
To summarize, the modern Damascus steel, especially if it’s forged or a counterfeit, can be worse or equal in terms of quality as compared to a regular stainless steel knife, which isn’t etched. If you do want to splurge on a true Damascus steel blade and will use the knife frequently, it would be a worthy purchase. However, if you are buying an original Damascus just for its looks and not the practicality, then it’s not worth it.